ethanbeute

Marketing | Environment | Culture

Craft Beer vs Macro Beer: On Budweiser’s Super Bowl Ad

“Proudly a macro beer.” Who would say such a thing? Why? And how?

For the answers, here’s a quick look at the 2015 Budweiser Super Bowl commercial.

Budweiser’s Super Bowl Ad

Here’s the entire message:

“Proudly a macro beer. It’s not brewed to be fussed over. It’s brewed for a crisp, smooth finish. This is the only beer beechwood aged since 1876.

“There’s only one Budweiser. It’s brewed for drinking, not dissecting. The people who drink our beer are people who like drinking beer. To drink beer brewed the hard way.

“Let them sip their Pumpkin Peach Ale. We’ll be brewing us some golden suds. This is the famous Budweiser beer. This Bud’s for you.”

That right there’s a stake in the ground. Or a line in the sand. A line on the other side of which are craft beers and micro brews.

Well done! That’s a very clear position.

 

What Precipitated the Position?

In short … sales. Declining sales.

Witness:Budweiser sales decline: Americans now drink more craft beer than Budweiser” (Slate, November 2014) | Choice quotes: “Craft beer’s growth pushes it past Budweiser in total barrels shipped.” and “It’s also a very specific testament to the decline of Budweiser, which these days is basically a beer without a purpose.”

Witness:Budweiser’s fall from grace, visualized” (Washington Post Wonkblog, December 2014) | Choice quotes: “The self-proclaimed ‘King of Beers’ is looking more like a pauper than a prince these days.” and “Per capita consumption of Budweiser has fallen by more than 43 percent since 2004.”

However: Budweiser and the Craft Beer Fallacy: How Myths Hide Trends” (Forbes, December 2014) | Choice quotes: “Realize that craft beer sales are up from a small base, and today ALL craft beer sales still account for only 7.6% of the market.” and “The problem with Budweiser sales – and sales of other big name brand beers – is a change in demographics.”

 

Response to the Budweiser Ad

In short … mixed. At best.

Witness:The Super Bowl’s Riskiest Ad: Is Budweiser laughing with or at Millennials?” (The Atlantic, February 2015) | Well worth the read if you’re into this topic, this piece packs cultural and demographic astuteness. Consolation: “This isn’t to denigrate the advertising people at Budweiser, who are perhaps in an impossible position.”

Witness:Analyzing Budweiser’s Hypocritical, Anti-Craft Beer Super Bowl Ad” (Paste Magazine, February 2015) | The tone taken here feels more fun and aggressive than The Atlantic’s analysis. Sample: “In fact, Anheuser is so non-threatened by craft beer that it saw fit to spend $9 million on a 60-second Super Bowl ad just to make sure you were aware of that fact.”

Response from a Brewer: An Open Letter on AB Buyouts and Advertising (Renegade Brewing, February 2015) | Personal note: their Elevation Triple IPA punches very well. Feel: the Founder and President had a lot on his chest; the ad seemed to be the last straw. Good, leading questions: “Could AB have been referring to their coffee pumpkin ale? As we all know as of January 23rd AB InBev produces a coffee pumpkin ale called Punkuccino under their newly acquired Elysian line of beers. Or do you think AB is even aware that they now produce this beer?”

The Roundup: “A Roundup of the Best Responses to the Budweiser Commercial” (Times Union, February 2015) | Rundown on this Roundup: a fun collection of videos, tweets, and even a Miller print ad that skewers Bud’s approach.

 

Ninkasi Brewing’s Video Response

Choice shots: the beer funnel shot and the leveling of the tree.

 

The Bottom Line

Yes, this is a bit of a lazy amalgam of links.

As a fan of craft beer and with an interest in brand and positioning, I found this ad and the response remarkable. So, some remarks.

Many took offense to the spot. And many made fun.

I found it to be a necessary attempt to create some sense of purpose for a tired product and brand whose target audience is aging. Certainly, the “real America” may be able to rally around a “real American” brand that turns its nose up to the hipster snobs who turn their noses up to fuss over their fussy beer.

A brand can define itself by what it is. Or by what it isn’t. With this execution, Budweiser’s agency found a fine balance.

I’d never spend a penny on Budweiser. I wouldn’t drink Budweiser at any price, including free. I probably spend too much money on craft beer (like the Ninkasi Double IPA above that I bought, poured, photographed, and fussed over). But … I have no contempt for this attempt.

Hit me up on Instagram for regular craft beer photos. And drop a comment. What’s your reaction to Budweiser’s Super Bowl ad?

3 Comments

  1. Well written analysis Ethan, and I respect your position as a marketing guy. I think it was a fairly risky ad though, it really only solidifies their position as a crappy beer to be enjoyed by a decreasingly small demographic. I think a better investment would be to try to compete with the craft beers by, you know, making better beer.

  2. AB’s spot *clearly* aims at the “Joe-the-Plumber, everyman, we’re not elitist” types, and it’s brilliantly done. And it also doesn’t make me want to drink a Bud any more than I ever did (which is never). Ninkasi’s response was great and asks a really good question: “If you’re not drinking beer for taste, what are you drinking it for?” Advantage: CRAFT.

  3. It would be so difficult and expensive to change the product and its position than it would to just acquire new brands to diversify your portfolio and grow your top line. That said, PBR did generate a big, hipster come up several years back that carries on … but it’s the same terrible beer (position > product).

    If deserved, Budweiser will one day go the way of Oldsmobile; Milwaukee’s Best is almost there. And, as with General Motors, AB will have a ton of other products and brands to sell.

    Its girth in distribution alone will keep Budweiser alive for decades. And if they can create some passionate fans, rather than people who just tolerate the product, by making fun of me … well, OK.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

*

© 2017 ethanbeute

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑